Benn vague at Hay
I've always had great respect for Tony Benn as being an honest socialist and principled politician. Last week I went to see him at the Hay Festival and enjoyed his intelligent analysis of British and world politics since his retirement in 2001.
However when I asked him about his understanding of what happened last month in Wales and Scotland he seemed far less sure footed and digressed into a vague argument against 'nationalism' and 'frontiers'.
I pointed out that surely the question related to self-confidence, self-government and self-empowerment; it had nothing to do with xenophobia or border controls. He came back on track and agreed that if that's what democracy dictated - "from the bottom up" - then so be it.
If a fine intellectual brain like his could not make an immediate and clear distinction between the politics of the BNP and SNP, what hope is there for our less able, tribal politicians?
Rhobert ap Steffan, Llangadog.
mailto:rhobert@uwclub.net



